Did the Open Science Quiz at the General Assembly spark your curiosity?
The Open Science Committee looks back at the key points to help you decode the issues, concepts and common misconceptions. Each week, find a dedicated focus to deepen your knowledge, one question at a time.
Focus #10: HAL vs ResearchGate ⚖️
Question / answers
98 respondents
Rate the following statements from 1 to 10 (1 = strongly disagree; 5 = no opinion; 10 = strongly agree):
10
There is no obvious difference between an open archive (HAL) and an academic social network (ResearchGate)
3.9
40%1
5%2
7%3
5%4
18%5
5%6
1%7
9%8
2%9
6%10
Comments
- HAL is a public, non-commercial open archive run by the CCSD (CNRS, Inria, INRAE). It guarantees long-term preservation of deposits and free access without registration.
- ResearchGate is a private company: full access requires an account, user data is exploited commercially, and the long-term availability of documents is not guaranteed.
- Uploads to ResearchGate do not always comply with publishing agreements: some publishers have already obtained the mass removal of articles.
- Deposits in HAL are recognised by our parent institutions and by funders. Nothing prevents you from then sharing the link to your HAL deposit on academic social networks.
Answers from the Open Science Quiz at the GeM 2026 General Assembly